Undoing gender butler deutsch undoing gender is a 2004 book. Undoing gender 1st edition judith butler routledge book. At first glance, the david reimer case appears to fully support the nature side of the debate because david was always a male since he had xy chromosomes. Judith butler project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks.
The johnjoan case to backtrack, the david reimer case started out with john money trying to disprove one of his biggest critics, milton diamond, a biology professor. David brenda had phalloplasty to create a penis20s, married and became stepdad. As this article was going to press in june of 2004, i was saddened to learn that david reimer took his life at the age of 38. At 14, having been informed of his past by his father, reimer decided to assume a male gender identity, calling himself david.
Examining gender identity and reassignment via butler and david reimer. Therefore for his own selfish gain he decided to use bruce and brian. Undoing genderis also a substantial reaction to gender trouble on some levels. At an early age, ricardo started working with his father. Finally, on march 14, 1980, reimer s parents told him the truth about his gender reassignment, following advice from reimer s endocrinologist and psychiatrist. David reimer and john money gender reassignment controversy. At the age of 6 months, a botched circumcision resulted in bruces. Jun 30, 2004 undoing gender constitutes judith butlers recent reflections on gender and sexuality, focusing on new kinship, psychoanalysis and the incest taboo, transgender, intersex, diagnostic categories, social violence, and the tasks of social transformation.
Oct 27, 2016 examining gender identity and reassignment via butler and david reimer. Gender identity is partly intrinsic, as evidenced when people feel inwardly compelled to break gender expectations, which frequen. Sex reassignment and allegories of transsexuality from the 2004 book undoing gender, by the feminist philosopher judith butler, addresses the case of david reimer. David reimer resource learn about, share and discuss david. From undoing gender by judith butler 960 words bartleby. In terms that draw from feminist and queer theory, butler considers the norms that governand fail to governgender and. Became withdrawn and unhappy, leading to his breakdowndepression worsened and in 2004 he shot himself. Money believed that gender identity and sexual orientation were determined completely by environment. Analysis of david reimer s from undoing gender 1742 words 7 pages while judith butlers claim in her essay from undoing gender is challenging, complex, and comprehensible, she provides somewhat enough evidence, and analysis of david reimers case to prove her claim that society uses language to set the norms of what a gender. Being brenda they were meant to show that gender was determined by nurture, not nature one identical twin raised as a boy and the other brought up as. Published in 2004 by routledge 270 madison avenue new york, ny 10016.
Undoing gender constitutes judith butlers recent reflections on gender and sexuality, focusing on new kinship, psychoanalysis and the incest taboo, transgender, intersex, diagnostic categories, social violence, and the tasks of social transformation. Jul 30, 2017 this is the story of david reimer, a canadian man who was the subject of a strange and ultimately tragic medical experiment conducted by dr. She is the maxine elliott professor in the rhetoric and comparative literature departments at the university of california, berkeley. Butler examines gender, sex, psychoanalysis and the way medicine and the law treat intersex and transgender people. He began as a male and returned to a male identity. By the time david reimer told his story, the notion of a mutable gender identity had taken hold. The case accelerated the decline of sex reassignment and surgery for unambiguous xy infants with micropenis, various other rare congenital malformations, or penile loss in infancy. After finishing this book, i looked up david reimer and was very saddened to find out that. David reimer august 22, 1965 may 4, 2004 was a canadian man who was born as a healthy male, but was sexually reassigned and raised as female after his penis was accidentally destroyed during circumcision. Undoing gender wikimili, the best wikipedia reader. The report and subsequent book about reimer influenced several medical practices, reputations, and. Neither of these is precisely a possession, but both are to be understood as modes of being dispossessed, ways of being for another, or, indeed, by virtue of another. Reimer is the individual at the center the reimer is the individual at the center the dispute between two opposing views.
On september 22, 1990, he married jane fontaine and became a stepfather to her three children. Judith pamela butler born february 24, 1956 is an american philosopher and gender theorist whose work has influenced political philosophy, ethics, and the fields of thirdwave feminist, queer, and literary theory. Allinall it is the nature of how their life played out, not their choice. The report and subsequent book about reimer influenced several medical practices, reputations, and even current understanding of the biology of gender. The book constitutes a reconsideration of her earlier view on gender performativity from gender trouble. The case of david reimer brought attention to the long contested debate of whether nature or nurture influenced behaviors in boys and girls. David reimer was born in 1965 in winnipeg, manitoba.
The boys uninjured brother, raised as a boy, provided to the experiment the perfect matched control. He stopped working to inform the janet and ron reimer that the true intentions of him convincing them to do a gender modification was to show that nurture, not nature, determined gender identity. In 1993, she began teaching at the university of california, berkeley, where she has served, beginning in 1998, as the maxine elliot professor in the department of comparative. In this work, the critique of gender norms is clearly situated within the framework of human persistence and survival. Pdf contesting gender in popular culture and family law. Not until undoing gender has butler seriously addressed the. To do this, she analyzes the case of david reimer, a boy who was raised as a girl after undergoing a sex reassignment at nineteen months of age, and who eventually transformed himself back into a man during adolescence colapinto 51. Analysis of david reimer s from undoing gender bartleby.
These things being said, undoing gender serves its aim of providing a hypothetical situation where people need not abide with gender restrictions. Apr 30, 2012 as this article was going to press in june of 2004, i was saddened to learn that david reimer took his life at the age of 38. David was born under the name bruce in 1965 along with his identical twin brother, brian. There are advantages to remaining less than intelligible, if intelligibility is understood as that which is produced as a consequence of.
Judith butler born february 24, 1956 is an american philosopher and gender theorist whose work has influenced political philosophy, ethics and the fields of feminist, queer 2 and literary theory. From the academic year 20112012 she will be a visiting professor at columbia. David reimer case essay example topics and well written. By 1997, reimer had undergone treatment to reverse the reassignment, including testosterone injections, a double mastectomy, and two phalloplasty operations. This case study as horrible as it is supports the idea that we have an innate biological gender identity which cannot be changed. Schillo 2011 specified that he promoted the theory that a kids gender identity was identified by environmental.
May 08, 2012 davids twin brother brian served as a control of sorts for the experiment. David reimer and chapter 3 of undoing gender i found the story about david reimer very interesting, sad and perplexing. Money was a prominent proponent of the theory of gender neutrality that gender identity developed. May 12, 2004 being brenda they were meant to show that gender was determined by nurture, not nature one identical twin raised as a boy and the other brought up as a girl after a botched circumcision. He thought that genes are essential however as far as gender is concerned the infant is basically neutral in the very first 2 years of life. In terms that draw from feminist and queer theory, butler considers the norms that govern and fail to govern gender and. Sep 16, 2004 undoing gender constitutes judith butlers recent reflections on gender and sexuality, focusing on new kinship, psychoanalysis and the incest taboo, transgender, intersex, diagnostic categories, social violence, and the tasks of social transformation. This is the story of david reimer, a canadian man who was the subject of a strange and ultimately tragic medical experiment conducted by dr. Butler revisits and refines her notion of performativity and focuses on the question of undoing restrictively normative conceptions of sexual and.
In terms that draw from feminist and queer theory, butler considers the norms that governand fail to governgender and sexuality as they. The johnjoan casein the mid1960s, psychologist john money encouraged the gender reassignment of david reimer, who was born a biological male but suffered irreparable damage to his penis as an infant. Davids twin brother brian served as a control of sorts for the experiment. To do this, she analyzes the case of david reimer, a boy who was. Focusing on the case of david reimer who was medically reassigned from male to female after a botched circumcision, butler reexamines the theory of. Focusing on the case of david reimer who was medically reassigned from male to female after a botched circumcision, butler reexamines the. Undoing gender news newspapers books scholar jstor september 2018 learn how and when to remove undoing gender constitutes judith butlers recent reflections on gender and sexuality, focusing on new kinship, psychoanalysis and the incest taboo, transgender, intersex, diagnostic categories, so. David brenda had phalloplasty to create a penis20s, married and became stepdad late 30s, brian killed himself and david blamed himself because of trauma the cause caused his family. Psychologist john money oversaw the case and reported the reassignment as successful and as evidence that gender identity is primarily learned. In 2004, shortly after his brother died from an overdose of antidepressants, david committed suicide.
Undoing gender deutsch undoing gender is a 2004 book by. Undoing gender butler deutsch undoing gender is a 2004. The new york times obituary 51204 mentions that his brother died two years earlier and that he was now separated from his wife. The case is most commonly referred to in medical literature as the john joan case and was made accessible to a larger audience through the book as nature made him.
The following year at 8 months old, both brothers were referred for circumcision at a local hospital after it emerged that they suffered from phimosis, a condition where the. Undoing gender 2004 undoing gender collects butlers reflections on gender, sex, sexuality, psychoanalysis and the medical treatment of intersex people for a more general readership than many of her other books. While judith butlers claim in her essay from undoing gender is challenging, complex, and comprehensible, she provides somewhat enough. Download for offline reading, highlight, bookmark or take notes while you read undoing gender. David peter reimer august 22, 1965 may 5, 2004 was a canadian man born biologically male but raised female following medical advice and intervention after his penis was accidentally destroyed during a botched circumcision in infancy. As nature made him tells the extraordinary story of david reimer, who, when finally informed of his medical history, made the. Oct 22, 2004 undoing gender ebook written by judith butler. David ricardo, born in the year 1772, spent most of his life in london. The case would become one of the most famous in modern medicineand a total failure. As nature made him tells the extraordinary story of david reimer, who, when finally informed of his medical history, made the decision to live as a male. Analysis of david reimer s from undoing gender 1742 words 7 pages while judith butlers claim in her essay from undoing gender is challenging, complex, and comprehensible, she provides somewhat enough evidence, and analysis of david reimer s case to prove her claim that society uses language to set the norms of what a gender should be and how one should act in accordance with ones gender.
Regardless of what gender people associate themselves with we all need to treat others with respect and dignity. Neither of these is precisely a possession, but both are to be understood as modes of being dispossessed, ways of being for another, or, indeed, by virtue of. The eighth episode of mental, house of mirrors 2009 deals with reimer s story. Feb 15, 2009 david reimer was born in 1965 in winnipeg, manitoba. The work that scholars were doing in other fields was undertaken and received in a context in which moneys conclusions were accepted as reliable. And to do ones gender in certain ways sometimes implies undoing dominant notions of. For this reason, it helps any reader become familiar with the arguments of the latter text before tackling this new one. Judith butler born 24 february 1956 is an american poststructuralist philosopher, who has contributed to the fields of feminism, queer theory, political philosophy, and ethics. At 14, reimer decided to assume a male gender identity, calling himself david. Undoing gender by judith butler, 2004 online research. It seemed like david was used as an experiment because he was the perfect contender for a study the psychologist, dr.
The case has also been treated by judith butler in her 2004 book undoing gender, which examines gender, sex, psychoanalysis, and the medical treatment of transsexual people. Undoing gender collects butlers reflections on gender, sex, sexuality, psychoanalysis and the medical treatment of intersex people for a more general readership than many of her other books. Some of what butler writes here is a redaction of gender trouble, and some a continuation of it. Butler revisits and refines her notion of performativity and focuses on the question of undoing restrictively normative conceptions. David reimer resource learn about, share and discuss. Page 2 what does the david reimer case have to say about. David reimer, a notorious test case in the naturenurture debate about gender. David reimer august 22, 1965 may 5, 2004 was a canadian man who. How does the case of david reimer treated by dr john.
She reflects on the life of david reimera person born with a penis that was. While many of butlers books are intended for a highly academic audience, undoing gender reaches out to a much broader readership. In the collection of essays undoing gender 2004, judith butler suggests that. David reimer was a canadian man born male but reassigned female and raised as a girl. The case of reimer is used to reexamine butlers theory of performativity that she originally explored in gender trouble. In the third chapter of her book undoing gender, judith butler sets out to examine the determinants of binary gender, and how one can define oneself as humaninhabit personhood, as she sayswithout conforming fully to any one of these determinants. In terms that draw from feminist and queer theory, butler considers the norms that governand. From undoing gender by jubith butler by shelby priddy on prezi. Undoing gender is a 2004 book by the philosopher judith butler. One of a pair of identical twins, his birthname was bruce and that of his brother brian.
David reimer project gutenberg selfpublishing ebooks. And so when we speak about my sexuality or my gender, as we do and as we must, we mean something complicated by it. David reimer was forced to experience the same dysphoria that trans people experience naturally. At the same time, it also seeks to dissolve our notions towards gender, thereby preempting us from taking the first step towards gender enlightenment.
1504 54 185 720 799 1441 1101 228 916 290 1050 866 1176 1410 530 858 719 748 706 220 1391 688 1266 734 1185 147 845 240 789 1017 230 764 412 1479 697 1433 1181 1442 1226 428 1153